Warm oak dining table and walnut chairs beside a large window overlooking an autumn woodland garden in a Forestville home.

Reading Forestville Home Prices One Sale at a Time

November 19, 2026

On August 7, a four-bedroom house at 8550 Templeman Road in Forestville closed at $2.5 million. Seven weeks later, on September 25, a rural residence at 8466 Templeman Road closed at $500,000. The two houses are on the same Forestville road, and one sold for five times the other. They show the main thing to understand about Forestville prices this fall. Very few homes sell here in any given stretch, and the town's market is really several smaller markets. So the average sale price mostly tells you which kind of house closed that month. It says little about what any one house is worth.

Buyers comparing West County towns this winter will see a Forestville figure that looks like it dropped sharply after summer. The county's own sales records explain why.

Ten weeks, two very different averages

The Press Democrat publishes a regular roundup of Forestville sales, built from title records filed with the county. For titles recorded from the week of August 10 through the week of August 23, 2026, it counted six residential sales. They averaged $1.27 million, or $677 per square foot. Three of those six sold for more than $1.5 million:

  • 8550 Templeman Road at $2.5 million
  • 5971 Green Lane at $1.74 million
  • 7480 Poplar Drive at $1.6 million

The paper's November 14 roundup covers titles recorded from the week of October 19 through the week of November 8. It also counted six residential sales. This time they averaged $467,500, or $496 per square foot. The highest price was $625,000, for a 1,292-square-foot house built in 2006 at 6312 Tristania Court. The lowest was $285,000, for a three-bedroom, one-bath house built in 1962 at 11241 Vellutini Road.

That is a 63 percent drop in the average in roughly ten weeks, and the kind of house closing changed over the same stretch. In the August window, houses of 1,641 to 3,000 square feet made up half the sales. By early November, every closing was a smaller home of about 1,300 square feet or less, among those whose size was recorded. With six sales per period, three closings at the top end are enough to swing the average.

Every Press Democrat roundup since late July shows the same pattern:

Title recording window, 2026 Highest listed sale Lowest listed sale
Week of July 13 to week of July 26 $1.03 million, 6760 Giovanetti Road $112,000, 10982 Terrace Drive
Week of July 27 to week of Aug. 9 $2.175 million, 7120 Covey Road $404,000, 11144 Ice Box Canyon Road
Week of Aug. 10 to week of Aug. 23 $2.5 million, 8550 Templeman Road $549,687, 11165 Hwy 116
Week of Aug. 24 to week of Sept. 13 $844,500, 8060 Park Avenue $415,000, 11699 Oak Road
Week of Sept. 21 to week of Oct. 18 $880,000, 6274 Van Keppel Road $231,500, 11550 Sunnyside Avenue
Week of Oct. 19 to week of Nov. 8 $625,000, 6312 Tristania Court $285,000, 11241 Vellutini Road

The estate-scale sales were concentrated in titles recorded from mid-July through late August. The windows since then are made up of smaller, mostly older houses, plus one new build. Among the homes whose size was recorded, the largest after August 23 was 8060 Park Avenue at 2,146 square feet, sold for $844,500.

One road, two markets

Back on Templeman Road, the two sales differ in almost every way. Number 8550 has 3,000 square feet and four bedrooms, was built in 1993, and sold for $832 per square foot. Number 8466 is a 1,462-square-foot rural residence built in 1977 that sold for $342 per square foot. Their price per square foot differs by a factor of about two and a half, and their total prices by a factor of five. The difference comes from the houses themselves. The address barely matters.

That is why a Forestville price question has to start with the property type. A full-time home in town, a small cabin, and a larger house on Green Lane, Giusti Road or Covey Road each have their own buyers, their own comparable sales, and their own pace. Mixing them into one town figure creates the swings in the table above.

Why price per square foot breaks down here

Agents often fall back on price per square foot when the average is noisy. In Forestville that measure gets noisy too. Take the two weeks from the week of July 27 through the week of August 9:

  • A 1,710-square-foot home at 11144 Ice Box Canyon Road, built in 1930, sold for $404,000, or $236 per square foot.
  • A two-unit property at 9870 River Road with 476 square feet of recorded living area sold for $698,000, which works out to $1,466 per square foot.

The River Road buyer did not pay six times more for each square foot of the same thing. They paid for a second unit, for the land, and for whatever made that property right for them, and the small recorded floor area spread that value across very few feet. Even the large homes vary. In that same window, 7120 Covey Road sold for $2.175 million at $499 per square foot, and 7495 Poplar Drive sold for $1.175 million at $670 per square foot. A larger house sold for less per foot, which is normal for big rural homes, where land and setting count for more than floor area.

What the county figures add

Sonoma County as a whole is large enough that the mix of homes evens out. According to Bay Area Real Estate Information Services, 356 residential properties sold in the county in September 2026. The median price was $779,500 and the median days on market was 43. In the same BAREIS comparison for September 2025, the median was $740,000, with 412 sales and 53 days on market. The California Association of Realtors counts only existing single-family homes. For Sonoma County in September 2026, it reported a median of $875,000, up 10.1 percent from a year earlier, with sales down 3.4 percent and a median of 61 days on market, compared with 76 the September before.

The two groups measure different sets of homes, so their numbers differ. Both show the same trend for September 2026, though. County prices were higher than a year earlier, there were fewer sales, and homes sold faster. Nothing in the countywide figures points to the kind of fall drop that Forestville's small-sample averages seem to show. That does not prove every Forestville home held its value. It does mean the town average cannot settle the question.

How to read a Forestville comp

The best evidence for a particular Forestville home comes from a few recent sales of very similar homes. The size of the house, its age, its parcel, and whether it has a second unit decide which sales count as comparable. Some examples from the recent records:

  • Small, older houses. For a two-bedroom house of about 1,000 square feet, relevant fall sales include 9779 Rio Vista Road, built in 1935, at $550,000, and 10987 Terrace Drive, built in 1961, at $295,000. Those two are about $250,000 apart. Condition and setting may explain part of a gap like that, and a walk-through tells you more about both than a sale record does.
  • Mid-size homes. For a three-bedroom house of 1,300 to 1,800 square feet, comparable sales include the newer homes on Van Keppel Road and Tristania Court, at $880,000 and $625,000.
  • Estate-scale properties. These are the summer sales on Templeman Road, Green Lane, Covey Road, Giusti Road and Hwy 116. They sold between $1.5 million and $2.5 million, and they are still the most recent sales at that size.

Keep the timing of these records in mind. The Press Democrat roundups include sales whose titles were recorded in a given window, even if the sale itself closed earlier. The paper says its figures come from county public records. So a sale can show up in the records a week or more after it actually happened.

For more on daily life in town, see our Forestville community page, and you can browse current Forestville homes for sale.

If you are weighing a Forestville property, or thinking about selling one, The Hedges • Davis Group can pull the handful of sales that compare to that specific home and walk through what they mean for its price. Request a personal consultation, and we will go through the Forestville sales with you in person.

Work With Us

If you're seeking a real estate professional who combines unparalleled dedication, market expertise, and genuine kindness, The Hedges • Davis Group is a perfect choice.